Introduction

Every year the Game Awards spark passionate debates. While some titles dominate the scene, others stay in the shadows yet remain equally influential. This article explores the ten games that were *excluded* from Game of the Year despite their critical and commercial success.

1. Dark Souls III

The final chapter from FromSoftware marked a turning point for the action‑RPG genre. Its legendary difficulty, dark atmosphere, and subtle storytelling captivated millions of players.

Why the exclusion?

In 2016 the competition was fierce with Doom, Overwatch and Inside. The jury favored high‑budget marketing titles, leaving Dark Souls III on the sidelines.

2. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild

This revolutionary title redefined open‑world adventure with unprecedented freedom and stunning artistic design.

Persistent impact

The survival mechanics, realistic physics and item system inspired dozens of indie games.

3. Red Dead Redemption 2

A narrative masterpiece that blends a moving story with a living, detailed world. Its technical execution is unparalleled.

  • Realistic graphics
  • Advanced NPC AI
  • Immersive gameplay economy

4. God of War (2018)

Redefining the series, this title offers deep storytelling and fluid combat that captivated critics and players alike.

“A return to roots with unmatched emotional depth.” – GameSpot

5. Persona 5 Royal

This Japanese RPG combined a distinctive visual style, memorable soundtrack and an engaging story about adolescence.

6. Horizon Zero Dawn

A post‑apocalyptic world where technology meets nature, featuring strategic battles against gigantic machines.

7. Super Mario Odyssey

This 3D adventure reinvented the platformer genre with limitless creativity and contagious humor.

8. Bloodborne

The FromSoftware title that introduced a dark gothic universe, extreme difficulty and fast combat.

9. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

An epic narrative RPG with rich side quests, complex economy and a living world.

10. Minecraft (Version 1.16)

This update introduced new biomes, mobs and mechanics that refreshed the infinite building experience.

Conclusion

These games demonstrate that merit is not always measured by nominations. Their influence endures in video‑game culture and inspires every new generation of developers. If you want to discover these essential titles, subscribe to our newsletter for personalized recommendations and stay updated on the latest gaming trends.

Original source
Polygon
The 10 greatest games to never get a GOTY nomination
https://www.polygon.com/greatest-games-no-goty-nominations/ →